Smart Cities
Maturity
capability 4 / 5
deployment 3 / 5
absorption 2 / 5 ← sets the score
Bound by incentives · trend flat.
Basis, source, vintage
The documented record is dominated by cancellations and scale-backs, and rigorous comparative outcome evaluation is still absent.
Source: Sidewalk Labs Quayside, Toronto cancelled May 2020 after years of data-governance controversy, having claimed 44,000 jobs and $14.2bn/yr GDP. Songdo (~$40bn) was designed for ~300,000 residents and had 167,346 as of 2020, about a third. Masdar City, planned as a zero-carbon city for 40,000 residents by 2016, was pushed to 2030 with ~5% of its footprint built and its goal downgraded to carbon-neutral (Griffiths & Sovacool, Energy Research & Social Science, 2020) (2020)
What it is
The application of sensing, data and automation to urban systems — traffic, energy, water, waste and public services.
What it does
It is a category of enablers applied to a place rather than a technology, and its record is the clearest demonstration in this book that buying capability is not the same as changing outcomes.
Common misconception
That the failures were technical. The recurring failure mode is buying sensing without changing the decision process that would have used it — the application gap, at municipal scale.
Steepens
- Government as a Service — large · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others)
- The Built-Environment Deficit — large · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 3 others)
- Energy Transition and Electrification — moderate
- Precision Everything — moderate · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 2 others)
- Water Security — moderate · ○ candidate constraint
What would change its gradient
- An operational team with authority to act on what is measured
- Procurement that buys outcomes rather than platforms
- Public consent obtained rather than assumed
Shares megatrends with
In the book
Why the Future Arrives Unevenly — Ch. 8 — The Rebuild of the Physical Base · Ch. 12 — Reading the Ramp · Ch. 15 — Society Out of Sync · Ch. 17 — Governments Running on Old Code
Sources
- The documented record is dominated by cancellations and scale-backs, and rigorous comparative outcome evaluation is still absent. Source: Sidewalk Labs Quayside, Toronto cancelled May 2020 after years of data-governance controversy, having claimed 44,000 jobs and $14.2bn/yr GDP. Songdo (~$40bn) was designed for ~300,000 residents and had 167,346 as of 2020, about a third. Masdar City, planned as a zero-carbon city for 40,000 residents by 2016, was pushed to 2030 with ~5% of its footprint built and its goal downgraded to carbon-neutral (Griffiths & Sovacool, Energy Research & Social Science, 2020) (2020).