---
id: smart-cities
name: Smart Cities
family: technological
tier: active
url: https://futuremap.talin.digital/e/smart-cities/
license: CC-BY-NC-4.0
---

# Smart Cities

## Maturity
2/5 — The documented record is dominated by cancellations and scale-backs, and rigorous comparative outcome evaluation is still absent.

Capability 4 · deployment 3 · absorption 2 · bound by incentives · flat

Source: Sidewalk Labs Quayside, Toronto cancelled May 2020 after years of data-governance controversy, having claimed 44,000 jobs and $14.2bn/yr GDP. Songdo (~$40bn) was designed for ~300,000 residents and had 167,346 as of 2020, about a third. Masdar City, planned as a zero-carbon city for 40,000 residents by 2016, was pushed to 2030 with ~5% of its footprint built and its goal downgraded to carbon-neutral (Griffiths & Sovacool, Energy Research & Social Science, 2020) (2020)

## What it is
The application of sensing, data and automation to urban systems — traffic, energy, water, waste and public services.

## What it does
It is a category of enablers applied to a place rather than a technology, and its record is the clearest demonstration in this book that buying capability is not the same as changing outcomes.

## Common misconception
That the failures were technical. The recurring failure mode is buying sensing without changing the decision process that would have used it — the application gap, at municipal scale.

## Steepens
- The Built-Environment Deficit (the-built-environment-deficit) — large
- Government as a Service (government-as-a-service) — large
- Precision Everything (precision-everything) — moderate
- Water Security (water-security) — moderate
- Energy Transition and Electrification (energy-transition-and-electrification) — moderate

## What would change its gradient
- An operational team with authority to act on what is measured
- Procurement that buys outcomes rather than platforms
- Public consent obtained rather than assumed
