The Redistribution of Power
Power redistributes West to East, state to platform, physical to digital chokepoints.
A megatrend's gradient is the minimum maturity of its enablers, not the mean.
Multipolarity and the New World Order
power distributes across several centres, with coalitions forming around issues rather than around blocs
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geopolitical Alignment | structural | large | 2/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Photonics & Optical Networking | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Space Technology | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Advanced Chips & Semiconductors | technological | moderate | 5/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Slow to register, fast to feel through prices and travel.
- Companies — years: Years. Supply chains reorganise around jurisdiction rather than cost.
- Governments — decades: Decades. This is the clock on which alliances and treaties move.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled negatively — collective action is harder without a coordinating centre.
What would prove this wrong
A durable return to a single ordering power, or the consolidation of two stable exclusive blocs with no significant hedging between them.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Institutional Decay of the Multilateral Order: More poles with fewer shared assumptions is the mechanism of institutional paralysis.
- amplifies → Middle-Power Agency and Non-Alignment 2.0: Multipolarity is what creates room for middle powers to decline to choose.
Digital Sovereignty
states reclaim control over digital infrastructure, data, and value chains
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blockchain & DLT | technological | marginal | 1/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
| Quantum Computing | technological | marginal | 1/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
| Geopolitical Alignment | structural | large | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 1 others) | |
| Sovereign Cryptocurrency | technological | moderate | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 1 others) | |
| Capital Availability | structural | large | 3/5 | ||
| Cryptography & Privacy Technologies | technological | large | 3/5 | ||
| Data Backup Embassy | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Edge Computing | technological | moderate | 3/5 estimate | ||
| Energy Price & Availability | structural | large | 3/5 | ||
| Nuclear & SMR | technological | marginal | 3/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
| Payment Rails | structural | large | 3/5 | ||
| Standards & Interoperability | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Cybersecurity | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Digital Ecosystems | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Photonics & Optical Networking | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Satellite Constellations (LEO) | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Space Technology | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Advanced Chips & Semiconductors | technological | large | 5/5 | ||
| Cloud & Datacentre Infrastructure | technological | large | 5/5 | ||
| Platforms | technological | moderate | 5/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Fast in switching a service, irrelevant at infrastructure scale.
- Companies — years: Six to eighteen months to migrate a cloud estate, with exit penalties designed to make it painful.
- Governments — decades: Decades. The Chips Act is a decade-scale instrument assessed at half its target inside two years.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled through Layer 1 — the energy the whole stack runs on.
What would prove this wrong
A state achieving credible depth across all ten layers from a standing start, or the dependency proving costless when tested — neither of which has happened.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Platform Power versus State Power: Sovereignty claims are states contesting rule-setting with platforms.
- amplifies → Contested Commons and Chokepoints: Every sovereignty layer that is not owned is a chokepoint someone else holds.
- dampens → Government as a Service: Sovereign infrastructure is the precondition for services a state can actually guarantee.
Platform Power versus State Power
technology platforms accumulate governance functions that states cannot easily reclaim
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sovereign Cryptocurrency | technological | marginal | 2/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
| Payment Rails | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 1 others) | |
| Standards & Interoperability | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 1 others) | |
| Digital Ecosystems | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Gaming Engines | technological | marginal | 4/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
| Social Credit System | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Platforms | technological | large | 5/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Fast, and the lock-in is what holds them.
- Companies — years: Fast at the platform end, slow for everyone dependent on terms they do not set.
- Governments — decades: Slowest. The tax coordination effort took a decade and delivered roughly half its projected revenue in year one.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled through the infrastructure footprint and through what the platforms optimise attention toward.
What would prove this wrong
A state matching platform capability on a layer that matters — as India's payment infrastructure did — reproduced in another jurisdiction and another layer.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Institutional Trust Decline: When platform rules bind more than public rules, public institutions look decorative.
Financialisation
financial claims grow faster than the real activity underlying them, and the pricing layer increasingly sets the terms for the productive one
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blockchain & DLT | technological | moderate | 1/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Geopolitical Alignment | structural | moderate | 2/5 | ||
| Sovereign Cryptocurrency | technological | moderate | 2/5 | ||
| Capital Availability | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Cryptography & Privacy Technologies | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Digital Identity & Verification | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Payment Rails | structural | large | 3/5 | ||
| Fintech & Payment Technology | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Cloud & Datacentre Infrastructure | technological | moderate | 5/5 | ||
| Platforms | technological | moderate | 5/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Fast in exposure, slow in understanding — most people's position is mediated by pensions they do not manage.
- Companies — years: Fast. Firms reorganise around whatever the capital markets reward.
- Governments — decades: Slow, and constrained: the tools that would reverse it also threaten the asset prices governments are committed to defending.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled through the discount rate — the further away a cost sits, the less a financial claim prices it.
What would prove this wrong
A sustained fall in the ratio of financial assets to GDP across major economies, without a crisis causing it.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → The Built-Environment Deficit: Housing treated as an asset class prices it away from the households that need it.
- amplifies → Institutional Trust Decline: Returns accruing where risk does not is the most legible unfairness in a modern economy.
Government as a Service
state functions are delivered as digital services, modularly, and increasingly judged against commercial service standards
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Digital Transformation | technological | large | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others) | |
| Generational Turnover | human | moderate | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others) | |
| Managerial Capability | human | moderate | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others) | |
| Regulatory Clarity | structural | moderate | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others) | |
| Smart Cities | technological | large | 2/5 | ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others) | |
| Data Backup Embassy | technological | marginal | 3/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
| Digital Identity & Verification | technological | large | 3/5 | ||
| Payment Rails | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Cybersecurity | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Data & Datafication | technological | moderate | 4/5 estimate | ||
| Digital Ecosystems | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Digitalization | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Fintech & Payment Technology | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Internet & Connectivity | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Social Credit System | technological | moderate | 4/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Fast. Citizens adopt a working government service as readily as a commercial one.
- Companies — years: Not the relevant actor, except as vendors.
- Governments — decades: Decades — and the constraint is bureaucratic culture and procurement rather than software.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Not coupled.
What would prove this wrong
A sustained reversal to counter-based delivery in a country that had digitised, or evidence that digital delivery systematically excludes enough people to be abandoned.
What this pushes on
- dampens → Institutional Trust Decline: Services that visibly work are the cheapest available trust intervention.
Autonomous and Asymmetric Warfare
the cost of projecting force falls, and capability distributes to actors that could not previously hold it
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geopolitical Alignment | structural | moderate | 2/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Cybersecurity | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Drones & Autonomous Systems | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Photonics & Optical Networking | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Satellite Constellations (LEO) | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Space Technology | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Weapons Autonomy & Dual-Use Systems | technological | large | 4/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Not applicable, except as the people it is used against.
- Companies — years: Fast. The commercial supply chain adapts in months.
- Governments — decades: Slow on doctrine, procurement and arms control, and the arms-control architecture is currently thinning rather than adapting.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled through conflict's environmental cost, which is rarely counted.
What would prove this wrong
An effective counter-autonomy defence deployed at scale and at a cost per interception below the cost per attacking unit — which would restore the economics of the incumbent.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Nuclear Proliferation and the Erosion of Arms Control: Conventional asymmetry raises the incentive to hold an unmatched deterrent.
Contested Commons and Chokepoints
critical supply chains and shared spaces become instruments of strategic leverage
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geopolitical Alignment | structural | large | 2/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Cryptography & Privacy Technologies | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Data Backup Embassy | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Marine & Ocean Technology | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Payment Rails | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ||
| Internet & Connectivity | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ||
| Photonics & Optical Networking | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Satellite Constellations (LEO) | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Space Technology | technological | large | 4/5 | ||
| Advanced Chips & Semiconductors | technological | large | 5/5 | ||
| Cloud & Datacentre Infrastructure | technological | moderate | 5/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Not the actor.
- Companies — years: Fast to reroute, slow to diversify a source that took a decade to qualify.
- Governments — decades: Multilateral governance is the slowest instrument in this book and the one most needed here.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: The commons in question are largely biosphere — ocean, atmosphere, Arctic — so the clocks are the same.
What would prove this wrong
A commons successfully governed under current institutions — a seabed mining code applied, high-seas enforcement that works, an orbital debris regime with teeth.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Autonomous and Asymmetric Warfare: Chokepoints are targets, and cheap systems make them cheap to threaten.
Demographic Power Shifts
the geography of working-age population diverges sharply from the geography of wealth and institutional capacity
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fintech & Payment Technology | technological | moderate | 4/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Satellite Constellations (LEO) | technological | marginal | 4/5 | marginal | marginal: not counted in the minimum |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: A decision taken in years that resolves over a lifetime.
- Companies — years: Years to adapt hiring; decades to adapt a business model built on a labour supply that is shrinking.
- Governments — decades: Decades, against a trend measured in generations, which is the mismatch Chapter 7 describes.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled through total load — headcount times behaviour, and behaviour is rising faster than headcount is falling.
What would prove this wrong
None available on the relevant timescale — which is the point. This is the most predictable trend in the book, and that is why the failure to act on it is diagnostic.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Multipolarity and the New World Order: Relative population and workforce size is the slow input to relative power.
Institutional Decay of the Multilateral Order
the post-1945 international institutions retain their form and lose their capacity to enforce their own rules
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Generational Turnover | human | moderate | 2/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Weapons Autonomy & Dual-Use Systems | technological | moderate | 4/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Barely visible until it is, at which point it arrives as a shortage or a border.
- Companies — years: Years. Trade-dependent firms feel enforcement gaps before governments acknowledge them.
- Governments — decades: Decades, and the direction is currently negative.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Directly coupled — every environmental commitment depends on the enforcement capacity that is decaying.
What would prove this wrong
A successful reform of a major multilateral institution's decision or enforcement mechanism — a reconstituted appellate function, a review conference producing a binding outcome, a governance reallocation that the incumbents accept.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Nuclear Proliferation and the Erosion of Arms Control: Arms control is the multilateral function most exposed to institutional failure.
- amplifies → Contested Commons and Chokepoints: Commons without functioning governance become contested by default.
Middle-Power Agency and Non-Alignment 2.0
middle powers leverage systemic competition to maximise autonomy and strategic optionality
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geopolitical Alignment | structural | moderate | 2/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Weapons Autonomy & Dual-Use Systems | technological | moderate | 4/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Not the relevant actor.
- Companies — years: Years. Firms in hedging states carry compliance for several regimes at once.
- Governments — decades: Fast by government standards — the posture can change within a term.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Not directly coupled.
What would prove this wrong
A forced binary that holds — sanctions or security guarantees making hedging materially more expensive than choosing, and middle powers choosing.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Digital Sovereignty: Non-alignment in practice means refusing to depend wholly on one stack.
Nuclear Proliferation and the Erosion of Arms Control
the treaty architecture that constrained nuclear weapons weakens faster than it is renewed
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nuclear & SMR | technological | moderate | 3/5 | ○ candidate constraint | |
| Weapons Autonomy & Dual-Use Systems | technological | large | 4/5 |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Absent from daily awareness, which is itself part of the mechanism.
- Companies — years: Not the relevant actor.
- Governments — decades: Decades — and the instruments now lapsing took decades to build.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: The tail risk that ends every other clock in this book.
What would prove this wrong
A successor treaty capping the two largest arsenals, or a review conference producing an agreed outcome after three consecutive failures.
Sovereign Wealth and State Capitalism
states act as investors and market participants rather than only as regulators of markets
| Enabler | Family | Weight | Maturity | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital Availability | structural | moderate | 3/5 | ○ candidate constraint |
Clock reading
- Individuals — months: Invisible.
- Companies — years: Fast — a sovereign investor on the register changes governance immediately.
- Governments — decades: Decades to build a fund, and the funds outlast the governments that built them.
- The biosphere — not ours to set: Coupled through what the capital is deployed into, which is increasingly a stated policy choice.
What would prove this wrong
Sustained net drawdown of sovereign fund assets across the major holders, or a broad retreat from equity positions to passive reserve holding.
What this pushes on
- amplifies → Financialisation: State capital operating on market terms deepens rather than counterweights financialisation.
- amplifies → Multipolarity and the New World Order: Capital is the instrument through which middle and Gulf powers buy position.
What holds this force back
- Geopolitical Alignment
- Generational Turnover
Sources for this force
- Agreement between the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg and the Republic of Estonia on the hosting of data and information systems, signed in Luxembourg 20 Jun 2017 by PMs Jüri Ratas and Xavier Bettel; approved by Luxembourg law of 1 Dec 2017 (Legilux a1029), ratified 2018, operational at LuxConnect's Tier IV facility since 2018, hosting ~10 critical registers under Estonian jurisdiction. Replicated by Monaco (Jul 2021); Bahrain has enacted a Data Embassy Law (2017–2021)
- David 1990; Brynjolfsson, Rock & Syverson 2021. The 95 per cent figure is the author's own estimate, marked as such in the text. (1990–2026)
- DOCUMENTED ABSENCE, re-confirmed Sep 2026. Nearest institutional evidence: OECD Going Digital Measurement Roadmap (2026); OECD Digital Government Outlook (2025/2026); Data Governance Hub 4th Annual Report (2024). No primary measurement of data fitness exists (2024-2026)
- E-009, E-010 (IEA Energy and AI); E-091, E-103 (2025–2026)
- E-103 (European Court of Auditors); industry capacity data (2025–2026)
- E-133 (TeleGeography/ICPC fault data; NATO Baltic Sentry) (2024–2025)
- E-138 (OECD, The Ocean Economy to 2050, 31 Mar 2025) (2025)
- E-150 (NPCI/UPI); E-154 (GSMA mobile money — counts are measurement, GDP-impact figures are industry belief) (2024–2026)
- E-174, E-175 (2025–2026)
- E-174, E-175; Space Foundation orbital economy figures; E-115 (Ostrom design principles) (2024–2026)
- E-176 (NIST IR 8547; Gidney arXiv:2505.15917; IBM roadmap; Google Willow) (2024–2026)
- E-176-adjacent; UN/ICRC joint call 5 Oct 2023, renewed 25 Aug 2026. **No numbered Dec 2025 UNGA resolution exists** (2023–2026)
- eIDAS 2.0 implementation timeline; Aadhaar and Estonian deployment record (2024–2026)
- ENISA Threat Landscape 2025 (Oct 2025, ref period Jul 2024–Jun 2025): 4,875 curated incidents; DDoS ~77% of reported incidents, phishing ~60% and vulnerability exploitation ~21.3% as leading vectors. CISA/ICS-CERT: 3,637 ICS advisories covering 12,174 vulnerabilities across 2,783 products (Mar 2010–Jan 2026). CISA Strategic Intent (2021): ICS 'often fail to receive software patches in a timely manner.' ISACA State of Cybersecurity 2025: 55% understaffed, 65% with unfilled positions (2024–2026)
- EU Digital Markets Act implementation record; company filings (2024–2026)
- European Commission eGovernment Benchmark 2024 (Jul 2024, ref 2022–23): EU27 overall 76/100 — User Centricity 93, Key Enablers 78, Transparency 67, Cross-Border 66; national eID availability 76% but cross-border eID use 37%. Corroborated by UN E-Government Survey 2024 (Denmark EGDI 0.9847; the very-high group is now the largest at 39%, 76 nations) and the OECD Digital Government Index (2022–2024)
- Eurostat, ICT Usage in Enterprises 2025 (Feb 2026); European Commission Digital Decade Report / Edge Observatory (2024-2026); Uptime Institute Global Data Center Survey (2025). The 75 per cent claim is INDUSTRY-BELIEF with no primary basis (2024-2026)
- FSB Global Monitoring Report (E-084); hyperscaler capex guidance (E-127); EuroHPC (E-091); ECA on the Chips Act (E-103) (2025–2026)
- GDPR 2012→2018 and EU AI Act 2021→2024→2027 timelines; Marchant, Allenby & Herkert (2011) (2011–2027)
- IAEA, Small Modular Reactors: Advances in SMR Developments 2024, and IAEA power-reactor statistics: 417 reactors operational at end-2024 (~377 GWe) across 31+ countries; 80+ SMR designs but only four in advanced construction (Argentina, China, Russia) (2024)
- IEA Energy and AI (E-009, E-010); Bruegel and IEA Electricity 2026 on EU industrial prices (E-090) (2025–2026)
- IMF COFER (E-035); PBOC e-CNY (E-036); ECB digital euro timeline (E-037); SWIFT and card-network actions 2022 (E-107) (2022–2026)
- ITU Facts and Figures (E-007) (2025)
- National aviation authority BVLOS rulemaking records; deployment evidence (2025–2026)
- NIST post-quantum standards and IR 8547 (E-176); deployment surveys (2024–2026)
- Paul David, AER (1990); Brynjolfsson, Rock & Syverson, AEJ Macro 13(1) (E-015) (1990 / 2021)
- PBOC (E-036); ECB (E-037) (2025–2026)
- Sidewalk Labs Quayside, Toronto cancelled May 2020 after years of data-governance controversy, having claimed 44,000 jobs and $14.2bn/yr GDP. Songdo (~$40bn) was designed for ~300,000 residents and had 167,346 as of 2020, about a third. Masdar City, planned as a zero-carbon city for 40,000 residents by 2016, was pushed to 2030 with ~5% of its footprint built and its goal downgraded to carbon-neutral (Griffiths & Sovacool, Energy Research & Social Science, 2020) (2020)
- SIPRI Yearbook 2026 (E-129); WTO Appellate Body and NPT RevCon record (E-130); Farrell & Newman (E-134) (2019–2026)
- Standard-setting as power anchored to China Standards 2035 (2020); Farrell & Newman, International Security 44(1) (E-134) (2019–2020)
- The Unity Runtime Fee episode is the citable case of platform power over dependent businesses: retroactive per-install charging announced 12 Sep 2023, developer revolt, a temporary office closure over a credible threat, CEO John Riccitiello's departure, and full cancellation of the fee in Sept 2024 under Matt Bromberg (2023–2024)
- TradeLens (Maersk/IBM) discontinuation announced 29 Nov 2022, access ended 31 Mar 2023, citing failure to reach commercial viability; we.trade liquidated 2022; Marco Polo Network insolvent 2023; Contour ceased 2024. ASX CHESS replacement (Digital Asset DLT) paused after Accenture review Nov 2022 and abandoned by May 2023 with an A$245–255m pre-tax write-down; ASX later penalised A$20.5m for misleading conduct (2022–2024)
- UK CMA, Cloud Infrastructure Services Market Investigation Final Decision, 31 Jul 2025 (ref 2024): Microsoft and AWS each hold 30–40% of a ~£9bn UK market; egress fees, technical barriers and licensing practices produce lock-in. Ofcom (Oct 2023): the three hyperscalers held 65–80% of the UK market in 2021; ~55% cite egress charges as a major switching barrier. Netherlands Algemene Rekenkamer, 15 Jan 2025: central government uses 1,588 cloud services, more than half from Microsoft, Amazon and Google, with no risk assessment for 84 of 126 material public cloud services (2021–2025)
- UN World Population Prospects 2024 (E-001, E-003, E-005) (2024)
- WKO Innovation Map 26/27 — TRL 8 / SRL 3, a +5 gap (E-142) (2026)