Managerial Capability
Maturity
2 / 5
Basis, source, vintage
Persistently low. The measured lag between adoption and reorganisation has not narrowed across three general-purpose technologies, and the intangible investment required is systematically under-made because it is expensed rather than capitalised.
Source: Paul David, AER (1990); Brynjolfsson, Rock & Syverson, AEJ Macro 13(1) (E-015) (1990 / 2021)
What it is
Whether the people running an organisation can redesign how work is done, rather than buying a tool and leaving the process intact. It is an organisational skill, not an individual talent, and it is scarcer than either capital or technology.
What it does
It converts a purchased capability into a changed output. Almost every study of general-purpose technology finds the same shape: buying the tool is fast, reorganising around it is slow, and the productivity shows up only after the reorganisation. Electrification took roughly forty years to appear in factory productivity, and the delay was managerial, not electrical.
Common misconception
That it is about technical literacy. Managers do not need to understand the model; they need to be able to change a process, a role and an incentive at the same time, and most organisations have no mechanism for doing all three at once.
Steepens
- Automation of Cognitive Work — large · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others)
- Hyper-automation of Industrial Production — large · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 2 others)
- The Application Gap — large · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 2 others)
- Distributed and Reshored Manufacturing — moderate · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others)
- Government as a Service — moderate · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 4 others)
- Precision Everything — moderate · ○ shared candidate constraint (with 2 others)
What would change its gradient
- Treating process redesign as a capitalised investment rather than an expense
- A management layer with the authority to change roles and incentives together, rather than one of the three
- Deployment measured on changed output rather than on seats licensed
Shares megatrends with
- Automation
- Digital Transformation
- Digitalization
- Workforce Trust
- AI & Machine Learning
- Data & Datafication
In the book
Why the Future Arrives Unevenly — Ch. 4 — Exponential and Its Discontents · Ch. 5 — The Optimisation of Everything · Ch. 16 — An Economy Without Capital · Ch. 21 — Designing for Selfishness
Sources
- Persistently low. The measured lag between adoption and reorganisation has not narrowed across three general-purpose technologies, and the intangible investment required is systematically under-made because it is expensed rather than capitalised. Source: Paul David, AER (1990); Brynjolfsson, Rock & Syverson, AEJ Macro 13(1) (E-015) (1990 / 2021).
- The Dynamo and the Computer: An Historical Perspective on the Modern Productivity Paradox — Paul A. David, American Economic Review, 1990
- The Productivity J-Curve — Brynjolfsson, Rock & Syverson, AEJ: Macroeconomics 13(1), 2021